A Whiskey question from a Canadian
Moderators: Oggar, Badfellow, Mr Boozificator, Artful Drunktective, mistah willies, NYDingbat, oettinger, Judge
- Captain Fruch
- Super Drunkard
- Posts: 141
- Joined: Mon Sep 01, 2008 9:44 am
A Whiskey question from a Canadian
Being that I have been a fan of Bourbon for most of my adult life, I've always wondered what those of you in the states think of Canadian whiskey. I often see mention of rye on drink related websites and sometimes get the impression that Canadian rye is considered to be fairly decent. For myself as a bourbon drinker, the stuff I consider to be good is probably only middle of the road for American drinkers. In terms of bourbon, there are the various labels of Jim Beam, Bulleit, Maker's Mark (being my personal overall favourite), and a few others, such as TJD which I consider shit and never touch. There are a few other variants of bourbon that show up from time to time yet it is an unreliable supply, so I make do with the choices I have. I do occasionally drink rye, and I guess I kind of take it for granted, some of the smaller distilleries in Canada. So I am wondering, for the Americans, what is the overall impression of Canadian Rye there? Is it like us up north with Bourbon, where we kind of view it as mostly kick ass, not only because it does, but also because its from a different district, or is it just another option? Also specifically, what are considered the best in terms of Canadian whiskey in the states?
"Don't you think you have had enough?" "Nonsense, I have not even begun to defile myself."
- Frankennietzsche
- Juicing Like Jackie
- Posts: 12348
- Joined: Mon Mar 17, 2003 9:13 pm
- Location: Master of the Meatloaf Winds
- Contact:
Re: A Whiskey question from a Canadian
Honestly, looking at a list of Canadain whiskeys, the only ones that one could regularly find around here Crown Royal, Canadian Club and Seagrams. I don't thaink that that is a very good cross section, and it has been so long since I have had any of those, that I really can't give an opinion.
Crown Royal comes with a dice bag, though, so it has always been a favorite with D&D players.
Crown Royal comes with a dice bag, though, so it has always been a favorite with D&D players.
“Süßen witwe Mutter-Hosen — kommst du hier mit mein knackenpfeife schnell, oder Ich zeige Ihnen mein Zuhälter Hand!”
"I am going to pistol-whip the next person who says 'shenanigans' "
"Rectum? It nearly killed him!"
"I am going to pistol-whip the next person who says 'shenanigans' "
"Rectum? It nearly killed him!"
- Resident Asshole
- Drinking God's Good Scotch
- Posts: 2834
- Joined: Tue Aug 23, 2005 8:09 am
- Location: Coming in your back door.
Re: A Whiskey question from a Canadian
So far as I know Canada doesn't really do ryes like they used to long ago, it's a bit of a misnomer. I have traveled there quite a bit but I don't live there so your mileage may vary. The majority of Canadian whisk(e)y which I have had is blended and pretty smooth. Not on par with bourbon though. I would love to try a true Canadian rye if they export one though.
Bourbon is my blood.
"Gren Label will rock on the show for me." bot rehan507
"women want to better express themselves. Dress up as their own performance this will be a lack of confidence." bot clshoo348
select backwards to God, his safekeeping a weapon homeopathy bold deed, president each opposite's cervix. bot klmn619
"Gren Label will rock on the show for me." bot rehan507
"women want to better express themselves. Dress up as their own performance this will be a lack of confidence." bot clshoo348
select backwards to God, his safekeeping a weapon homeopathy bold deed, president each opposite's cervix. bot klmn619
Re: A Whiskey question from a Canadian
Isn't Canadian Whiskey made with more rye in the mash bill than your standard bourbon? The brown liquor expert at my favorite candy store informed me of this. The veracity of this statement has yet to be determined.
it came up as I was eyeing a bottle of Whistle Pig Rye. He stated that while good it was really just a Canadian whiskey. Therefore overpriced for what it was. With today's liquor marketing I don't find it to be to much of a stretch but have done no research to discover the truth. Instead I bought the Sazerac... a product of Kentucky.
*edit after research into who owns Sazerac
it came up as I was eyeing a bottle of Whistle Pig Rye. He stated that while good it was really just a Canadian whiskey. Therefore overpriced for what it was. With today's liquor marketing I don't find it to be to much of a stretch but have done no research to discover the truth. Instead I bought the Sazerac... a product of Kentucky.
*edit after research into who owns Sazerac
Now you're ready for some anti-dry-otics!-BeerMakesMeSmarter
If worms had daggers, birds wouldn't fuck with them-Todd Snider
Blackout and be extraordinary-Absinthe of Malice
If worms had daggers, birds wouldn't fuck with them-Todd Snider
Blackout and be extraordinary-Absinthe of Malice
Re: A Whiskey question from a Canadian
I have a very slim selection around here also. I have been enjoying Crown Reserve quite a bit lately, too bad it is so expensive. I am going to have to give Canadian Club a whirl sometime, it is a decent amount cheaper than Crown here.
-
- Moderator
- Posts: 9790
- Joined: Tue Apr 15, 2003 7:29 pm
- Location: In The Liquor Cabinet
Re: A Whiskey question from a Canadian
Sadly Canadian whisk(e)y is nigh impossible to find in the UK. Even the once ubiquitous Canadian Club has vanished from the shelves.
I put this down, to a large degree, to the extermination of the old-shool off-license (the UK equivalent of a liquor store) by the big supermarket chains. However, that is a gripe for another thread.
I put this down, to a large degree, to the extermination of the old-shool off-license (the UK equivalent of a liquor store) by the big supermarket chains. However, that is a gripe for another thread.
"If I had all the money that I've spent on drink, I'd spend it on drink!"
"The trouble with internet quotes is that one can never be sure if they are genuine." - Abraham Lincoln
Kindly listen to this, please.
ドロンケン
![Image](http://i1291.photobucket.com/albums/b551/PalinkaReal/images-37_zps41bc6596.jpeg)
![Image](http://i901.photobucket.com/albums/ac220/padraigpalinka/pirateflag_zps7769d25d.gif)
"The trouble with internet quotes is that one can never be sure if they are genuine." - Abraham Lincoln
Kindly listen to this, please.
ドロンケン
![Image](http://i1291.photobucket.com/albums/b551/PalinkaReal/images-37_zps41bc6596.jpeg)
![Image](http://i901.photobucket.com/albums/ac220/padraigpalinka/pirateflag_zps7769d25d.gif)
- Jiggers McCoy
- Inebriate Savant
- Posts: 891
- Joined: Wed Jan 13, 2010 6:41 pm
- Location: Tampa
Re: A Whiskey question from a Canadian
For me, Canadian whisky, even the good stuff, is just missing something. There's no muscularity, no backbone. Like somebody took a "Whiskey" flavor packet, sprinkled it into some cheap vodka and screwed off for the rest of the afternoon. I'd take a cheap bourbon over Crown any day.
• "Avoiding the darker alcohols like bourbon, red wine and dark rum might lessen [a hangover] and you might also dance better if you wear a tutu instead of trousers." - FKR
• "If you wanna 'talk about' my drinking, it better be about how fucking awesome it is." - Me
• "If you wanna 'talk about' my drinking, it better be about how fucking awesome it is." - Me
Re: A Whiskey question from a Canadian
You people have problems... I`m shaking my drunken head. In stupid ol`germany you can be lucky enough to find paint thinner resemblling anything more "exoctic" than JB, JW, TJD, Ballentines and a whole lot of Tullamore Dews. But no salesclerk to be found who might tell the difference between bourbon and scotch other than reading to you the location of said liquor which is obviously printed on the front of the bottle.
Still you have the Toronto Raptors, watching them makes me feel dizzy too somehow, touche!
Still you have the Toronto Raptors, watching them makes me feel dizzy too somehow, touche!
Drink!
![Image](https://i.imgur.com/AabSG4I.png)
![Image](https://i.imgur.com/hnIPlab.jpg)
![Image](https://i.imgur.com/AabSG4I.png)
![Image](https://i.imgur.com/hnIPlab.jpg)
- Mr. Viking
- Hooching Like Hemingway
- Posts: 3949
- Joined: Fri Nov 25, 2011 7:23 am
- Location: Norris Green
Re: A Whiskey question from a Canadian
still fairly popular in northern Ireland along with such delights as Crown Royal and the Scotches Stewarts Cream of the Barley and The Real MackenziePalinka wrote:Sadly Canadian whisk(e)y is nigh impossible to find in the UK. Even the once ubiquitous Canadian Club has vanished from the shelves.
I put this down, to a large degree, to the extermination of the old-shool off-license (the UK equivalent of a liquor store) by the big supermarket chains. However, that is a gripe for another thread.
"I spent all of my money on cars, women and booze, the rest of it I squandered" G. Best
Re: A Whiskey question from a Canadian
Real MacK is most shootable, highly recommend for endrunkening purposes.
- Mr Boozificator
- Boozing Like Bukowski
- Posts: 4981
- Joined: Sat Dec 12, 2009 6:28 pm
Re: A Whiskey question from a Canadian
Bur, have you been dancing with the polar bears again?Bur wrote:Real MacK is most shootable, highly recommend for endrunkening purposes.
"I never want to go to bed if there are still beers in the fridge, but then I am always hopeful that there are beers left in there when I wake up.". Thirstydrunk.
"We all look for happiness, but without knowing where to find it: like drunkards who look for their house, knowing dimly that they have one." Voltaire
"The prince of darkness is a gentleman." Shakespeare.
"We all look for happiness, but without knowing where to find it: like drunkards who look for their house, knowing dimly that they have one." Voltaire
"The prince of darkness is a gentleman." Shakespeare.
- Resident Asshole
- Drinking God's Good Scotch
- Posts: 2834
- Joined: Tue Aug 23, 2005 8:09 am
- Location: Coming in your back door.
Re: A Whiskey question from a Canadian
Perhaps this is because most Canadian whiskeys are blends? Bourbon has the strictest requirements of all liquor as far as how it is made and the ingredients, therefore it just makes sense that bourbon would have a more consistent flavor and more bite.Jiggers McCoy wrote:For me, Canadian whisky, even the good stuff, is just missing something. There's no muscularity, no backbone. Like somebody took a "Whiskey" flavor packet, sprinkled it into some cheap vodka and screwed off for the rest of the afternoon. I'd take a cheap bourbon over Crown any day.
Bourbon is my blood.
"Gren Label will rock on the show for me." bot rehan507
"women want to better express themselves. Dress up as their own performance this will be a lack of confidence." bot clshoo348
select backwards to God, his safekeeping a weapon homeopathy bold deed, president each opposite's cervix. bot klmn619
"Gren Label will rock on the show for me." bot rehan507
"women want to better express themselves. Dress up as their own performance this will be a lack of confidence." bot clshoo348
select backwards to God, his safekeeping a weapon homeopathy bold deed, president each opposite's cervix. bot klmn619
-
- Moderator
- Posts: 9790
- Joined: Tue Apr 15, 2003 7:29 pm
- Location: In The Liquor Cabinet
Re: A Whiskey question from a Canadian
*Ahem*...I think that are some Scottish (and probably a few Irish and Welsh) Single Malt Whisky Distilleries that might offer a different view...Resident Asshole wrote:...Bourbon has the strictest requirements of all liquor as far as how it is made and the ingredients...
"If I had all the money that I've spent on drink, I'd spend it on drink!"
"The trouble with internet quotes is that one can never be sure if they are genuine." - Abraham Lincoln
Kindly listen to this, please.
ドロンケン
![Image](http://i1291.photobucket.com/albums/b551/PalinkaReal/images-37_zps41bc6596.jpeg)
![Image](http://i901.photobucket.com/albums/ac220/padraigpalinka/pirateflag_zps7769d25d.gif)
"The trouble with internet quotes is that one can never be sure if they are genuine." - Abraham Lincoln
Kindly listen to this, please.
ドロンケン
![Image](http://i1291.photobucket.com/albums/b551/PalinkaReal/images-37_zps41bc6596.jpeg)
![Image](http://i901.photobucket.com/albums/ac220/padraigpalinka/pirateflag_zps7769d25d.gif)
- Resident Asshole
- Drinking God's Good Scotch
- Posts: 2834
- Joined: Tue Aug 23, 2005 8:09 am
- Location: Coming in your back door.
Re: A Whiskey question from a Canadian
Do you mean the distilleries' own rules or the legality? I'm talking about the legal definition of the liquor. I will agree with you in the sense that Scotch has some pretty specific rules, but just the fact that bourbon (BTW, I should have clarified "straight" bourbon) has to be aged in new barrels but Scotch can be aged in a bourbon barrel says a lot to me.Palinka wrote:*Ahem*...I think that are some Scottish (and probably a few Irish and Welsh) Single Malt Whisky Distilleries that might offer a different view...Resident Asshole wrote:...Bourbon has the strictest requirements of all liquor as far as how it is made and the ingredients...
Anyway, part of my point was that Canadian whiskey can be distilled quite high (as can Scotch and Irish whiskey), thus negating a lot of the "woody" flavors. Obviously there is room for debate, but I have spent a lot of time drinking in Canada, Ireland, Scotland and of course Kentucky, as well as touring the distilleries so I feel I have a decent handle (hehe) on it.
This is not to say that one is better than the other, I like them all in different ways but the varying requirements are interesting to me.
Bourbon is my blood.
"Gren Label will rock on the show for me." bot rehan507
"women want to better express themselves. Dress up as their own performance this will be a lack of confidence." bot clshoo348
select backwards to God, his safekeeping a weapon homeopathy bold deed, president each opposite's cervix. bot klmn619
"Gren Label will rock on the show for me." bot rehan507
"women want to better express themselves. Dress up as their own performance this will be a lack of confidence." bot clshoo348
select backwards to God, his safekeeping a weapon homeopathy bold deed, president each opposite's cervix. bot klmn619
- Badfellow
- Juicing Like Jackie
- Posts: 10733
- Joined: Tue Oct 04, 2005 3:05 pm
- Location: Republic of Drunkardia
Re: A Whiskey question from a Canadian
Candian Whiskey has a speckled reputation considering that it is a blended product and ranges greatly in quality. However, even those worst quality examples of Cannuckery are generally reputed to be relatively smooth in comparison to their international, bottom-shelf counterparts. The blending process has historically been used by distillers as a means of promoting the consistency of what goes into the bottle and, as is the case with Canadian, a way to smooth the rough edges from lesser aged product.
As for the flavor comparison, Bourbon is undisputably more complex than Canadian. Much of that is due to the aging and the requirement that a NEW charred oak barrel be used for each batch. This is where you get the vanilla and woodiness that you typically never find in Canadian.
Is Canadian worth the drink? Absolutely, eh. Especially the rye. One of the best ryes I've ever tipped was from the provinces. But given a choice I'll tend to gravitate back toward the Kentucky stuff.
As for the flavor comparison, Bourbon is undisputably more complex than Canadian. Much of that is due to the aging and the requirement that a NEW charred oak barrel be used for each batch. This is where you get the vanilla and woodiness that you typically never find in Canadian.
Is Canadian worth the drink? Absolutely, eh. Especially the rye. One of the best ryes I've ever tipped was from the provinces. But given a choice I'll tend to gravitate back toward the Kentucky stuff.
ພາສາລາວNONE GENUINE WITHOUT MY SIGNATUREພາສາລາວ